NANA: love, loss & the manga that still haunts us (or at least, me).

Welcome, everyone, to Cappuccino & Croissant—the podcast that inhales pop culture while sipping on sharp-edged analysis. Today, we’re diving into a manga that has broken hearts, fueled countless punk makeovers, and left its fans with a craving for closure so intense it practically created its own subgenre of heartbreak. I’m talking about NANA, by the legendary Ai Yazawa. Even before I’d ever cracked open a single volume of NANA, my friends were calling me “Hachiko,” as if this manga and I were destined to meet. Maybe they were right. Because from the first page, it felt like NANA wasn’t just telling a story—it was holding up a mirror. A mirror that reflected my own obsessions, my longing for independence, and even my dream of one day owning Shin’s lighter, the legendary Vivienne Westwood piece that has haunted me since I was 14. So today, we’re exploring this cult classic that defined a generation… and, in more ways than one, shaped who I am now.

If you think shōjo manga is all pink hearts and sappy love triangles, think again. NANA will knock you sideways—like spilling your latte on your study notes five minutes before a final exam. It’s the story of two women, both named Nana, who move to Tokyo only to discover that adult life isn’t exactly warm and fuzzy (especially in Nana Osaki’s hardcore punk world).

But why talk about NANA today? Because it’s 2025, and despite being on hiatus since 2009, this manga is more alive than ever in the hearts of its fans. It tackles codependency, social pressure, and the ache of an unfinished masterpiece. In short, it’s an emotional black hole you can’t escape. If you’ve never read it, buckle up for one wild rollercoaster. If you have, well—grab tissues and tune your guitar, ‘cause you already know the ride’s about to get bumpy! Here’s our roadmap for this deep-dive article:

1. The World of NANA: Tokyo, where dreams meet disillusion.

2. The Two Nanas: two ways of loving, messing up, and losing oneself.

3. Love & Dependency: the toxic heart of the story.

4. Core Themes: loneliness, illusions of happiness, societal pressure on women…

5. Cultural Impact: Why we’re still obsessed with NANA.

Fasten your seatbelts, get your punk spikes ready—let’s roll!

Tokyo: a mirror of dreams & disappointments

In NANA, Tokyo is both a playground and a lethal trap. You might think Ai Yazawa picked Japan’s capital for its flashy modernity, but there’s more intention behind it: Tokyo is essentially its own character, feeding on the hopes and ambitions of our heroines while gnawing at their vulnerabilities.

It’s the year 2000. Nana Komatsu (“Hachi”) and Nana Osaki leave their backwater towns, convinced Tokyo holds the key to freedom, modernity, and big adventures. Little do they realize they’re walking straight into an unforgiving adult world, where loneliness can sting harder than any quiet life in the countryside.

Yazawa shows Tokyo’s split personality right from the start. On one hand, you’ve got the bohemian lifestyle: tiny, overpriced apartments, smoky live houses, late-night jam sessions, and that thrilling high of “Yes! I’m finally living the dream.” On the other, you’ve got bleak reality: sky-high rents, cramped subways, precarious jobs, and a cutthroat music industry. Tokyo will smile at your ambitions—then serve you up for dinner if you can’t keep pace.

This dynamic is spotlighted through NANA’s music scene. By creating two major bands—Blast (all about raw, punky energy) and Trapnest (the mainstream pop-rock sensation)—Yazawa explores the duality between dreams and reality. Tokyo may promise you infinite creative freedom, but it also comes with fierce competition, financial pressure, and media scrutiny that can crush you overnight.

Tokyo perfectly embodies the contradictions of adulthood depicted in NANA: The euphoria of possibility collides with the bitterness of daily responsibilities. You can “make it” one day, then lose everything the next. Hachi imagines a rom-com life in the big city, only to face emotional isolation. Nana Osaki aims to conquer Tokyo through music, only to discover that success hangs on record labels, paparazzi, and the corporate machine.

But Yazawa isn’t just drawing Tokyo as a hip backdrop. She’s dissecting Japanese society, where social status, family expectations, and a deeply entrenched idea of female roles all converge. Hachi quickly learns that to be “acceptable,” you gotta be coupled and “settled.” Meanwhile, the free-spirited Nana Osaki gets slammed by how little a lone rock singer can weigh against the industry’s demands. As each character makes—and breaks—relationships, Tokyo stands as the stage magnifying all their flaws and strengths.

In short, Tokyo is not just a setting in NANA; it’s a catalyst. The city reveals who you really are, fueling your hopes while smashing your illusions if you’re not tough enough. Contradictions abound: the lure of adult freedoms vs. the reality of betrayal, social pressure, and crippling loneliness. That’s why we say Tokyo is a character: it takes, it gives, it devours, and it forces the heroines to reckon with their personal baggage.

Through Tokyo’s lens, NANA shows the harsh reality for young dreamers caught between longing for success and the raw mechanics of a city that trades everything—love, friendship, even stardom. NANA flings aside the sugary image of a typical shōjo to highlight that gritty clash of bohemia vs. capitalism, of romantic fantasy vs. the real world. Yazawa’s Tokyo is a living, breathing paradox that electrifies every emotional beat, giving NANA a potent realism seldom seen in shōjo (or even josei) manga.

The two Nanas: two visions of life & love

At the core of NANA is the fascinating interplay between two women who share the same name—yet come from polar-opposite backgrounds and mindsets. Ai Yazawa crafts two distinct female archetypes whose strengths and vulnerabilities highlight the many faces of codependency.

Nana Osaki: the “independent” who’s chained up

Hard on the outside, wounded on the inside 

Nana Osaki radiates rebellious energy: punk outfit, sharp tongue, bohemian lifestyle, zero interest in typical “domestic bliss.” The poster child for the “free woman”—or so it seems. Beneath that tough exterior lies a troubled past: an absent mother, a turbulent adolescence, and an all-consuming need for validation. She built her pride into a shield, terrified of being abandoned again.

Sarcasm as self-defense 

So yes, Nana O. can appear coolly self-sufficient—until someone she loves goes AWOL, and her whole world shatters. One missed phone call from Ren? She spirals. The stark irony: the more she proclaims her independence, the more she panics when a loved one pulls away.

Toxic ties: Ren and the dream of success 

While Nana O. boasts, “I don’t need anyone,” she’s essentially lost without Ren, her first love. Their bond is pure passion—a vortex of dependence that leaves her frantic whenever they’re apart. The same desperation shows in her quest for stardom with her band, Blast: she’s desperate to prove she matters, that she’s more than just “Ren’s girlfriend.” Her shot at success is also a trap, another measuring stick for her self-worth.

The paradox of “freedom” 

Nana flees stable love for fear of heartbreak, yet flees being alone for fear of having nobody. It’s a constant swing between “Woohoo, I’m a punk rock queen!” and “Oh God, no one’s calling me—what if I’m actually worthless?” Ai Yazawa shreds the notion of a flawless “tough girl,” showing us that even the boldest rebel can be undermined by deep-seated abandonment issues.

Nana Komatsu (Hachi): love as both engine and cage

Naïve, dreamy—but not dumb 

Opposite Nana Osaki is Nana Komatsu, affectionately dubbed “Hachi.” Sweet, pink, hearts-in-eyes, she seems the quintessential romantic. In truth, she’s fully aware when a situation is toxic; she just can’t handle being alone, so she’ll cling to anyone who shows her affection.

An overwhelming need to be loved 

That’s Hachi’s Achilles’ heel: she’s so desperate for love that she’ll endure betrayals (like Shōji’s cheating), manipulation (looking at you, Takumi), and even risk losing her best friend (Nana O.). For Hachi, being loved is more than a preference—it’s survival. She was raised to believe a woman’s worth hinges on snagging a Prince Charming before she ends up lonely and shunned.

From hopeful Cinderella to trapped housewife 

Hachi’s big dream is the fairytale: a wedding, a cozy home, kids. Reality slaps her hard when she discovers Shōji’s infidelity, Takumi’s toxic control, and Nobu’s arrival…too late. Eventually, she “chooses” a marriage that offers material security (but leaves her emotionally starving). She’s living the nightmare she once dreaded: dependent on a husband who barely treats her like an equal.

A painful growth process 

Yet Hachi isn’t a helpless damsel. Over time, she recognizes her self-sabotage and tries to own the consequences. Unfortunately, her awakening comes at a steep cost: her freedom, her special bond with Nana Osaki, even the chance at genuine love. It’s a harsh lesson about how chasing “perfect love” can backfire when driven by fear rather than genuine choice.

A brutal warning about codependency 

Hachi embodies the “Cinderella syndrome,” the social conditioning that a woman’s prime objective is to be chosen by a knight in shining armor. Yazawa pulls no punches showing how that can erode your self-esteem, leading to damaging liaisons. Over and over, Hachi’s decisions revolve around her terror of solitude. If you’re looking for a cautionary tale about confusing “being saved” with “being loved,” Hachi is Exhibit A.

Two faces of the same fear

This is the magic of NANA: the ever-present contrast between two varieties of dependence. Nana O. trumpets her autonomy yet craves closeness to fill her void. Hachi throws herself headlong into love to avoid being alone. They form a bond that’s at once beautiful and destructive, each seeing in the other something they lack themselves. But both are fundamentally driven by fear—of being left behind, of not being enough. Ai Yazawa’s skill lies in depicting how, whenever one Nana seems ready to overcome her issues, the other tumbles deeper into hers. Ultimately, these two heroines embody the complexities of contemporary womanhood: the rebel and the romantic, each struggling to find a balanced love without losing their sense of self. It’s a question everyone can relate to: “Can I love someone without disappearing in the process?” That’s the universal chord NANA strikes, hitting readers square in the heart.

Love & Dependency: The Heart (and Toxin) of NANA

Love is the driving force of NANA, though not in the fluffy sense. Ai Yazawa paints a world where nearly every relationship is toxic or riddled with illusions, as if “togetherness” naturally morphs into “slowly destroying each other.” It’s not just about sad romances, either—Yazawa is determined to show how dependency is the secret ingredient fueling each character’s dysfunction, whether it’s a raging passion, financial safety, or sheer convenience.

So, Why Are All These Relationships So Toxic?

• Nana & Ren: destructive passion 

From the outset, they’re the epitome of wild, soulful love. But that raw connection quickly becomes their undoing. Ren heads to Tokyo to join Trapnest; Nana feels betrayed. Time and again, their reunions burst with desire, jealousy, fear, press speculation, and a creeping inferiority complex. Their legendary romance is intense enough to drown them both—Ren turns to drugs, Nana clings to the notion that their passion is her identity. Yazawa shows us how “true love” can quickly morph into something you can’t control, fueling addiction and heartbreak.

• Hachi & Takumi: security vs. real affection 

Takumi is the classic “prince” figure: good looks, money, success. He’s everything Hachi wants… on paper. Except he’s also manipulative, unfaithful, and arrogant. For Hachi, the comfort of being materially provided for blinds her to his dark side. Or maybe it doesn’t blind her; she’s just too scared to be on her own to break free. Their relationship becomes a toxic deal—she trades independence for a false sense of safety.

• Nobu & Hachi: the right person at the wrong time 

Nobu offers genuine love. He respects Hachi, meets her on equal ground, and might’ve been the best partner she could hope for… …except she’s pregnant, tangled in social pressures, and absolutely cannot picture a life without the financial stability Takumi presents. So the one decent love story is tragically over before it starts, highlighting the universal cruelty in NANA: even healthy feelings don’t stand a chance when confronted with fear, pride, and real-world barriers.

Piecing Together Shattered Romantic Ideals

1. A critique of toxic romantic ideals 

Yazawa dismantles the fairy-tale illusions of “perfect love” and “forever after.” Whether it’s Ren (the rocker dream), Takumi (the wealthy prince), or Nobu (the sweet friend), none of them deliver a balanced, healthy relationship. NANA calls out how society glorifies an unattainable form of love, ignoring the messy realities of human need and vulnerability.

2. Love as a multilayered dependence

• Emotional: Nana/ Ren, Hachi/ Takumi—abandonment anxiety fuels their clinging.

• Material: Hachi picks Takumi for financial safety, letting money warp their bond.

• Psychological: everyone projects fantasies onto their partner—Hachi’s “prince,” Nana’s “rock god.” No one meets as full individuals; they meet as incomplete puzzles, hoping the other fills in the gaps.

3. A deliberate absence of healthy models 

Many manga series feature at least one “ideal couple” for readers to root for. NANA doesn’t, by design. Almost every bond is clouded by lies, insecurities, or repressed trauma. Yazawa is confronting you with bleak honesty: remain alone or cling to toxicity, fight for your freedom or compromise it…each path exacts a heavy toll.

In essence, NANA doesn’t treat love as salvation; it’s more like a mirror reflecting every crack in our armor. We jump into relationships to avoid loneliness or the harshness of the outside world, but the illusion breaks sooner or later. Yazawa’s unwavering lens on Japan’s (and arguably the world’s) romantic ideals shows how “being loved” often collides with reality. No easy solutions here—just raw truths about emotional transactions that might cost us more than we can pay.

Central Themes: Why NANA Feels So Real

Ai Yazawa loaded NANA with universal themes—loneliness, broken dreams, regret, societal pressures—while anchoring it firmly in Japanese culture. It’s more than your standard shōjo fare; it’s an unvarnished plunge into tough truths and flawed psyches.

• Loneliness & the illusion of happiness 

You see it everywhere in NANA: even when characters find success or companionship, a hollowness lingers. Hachi gets married, has a child, but her husband is aloof at best, and she’s left alone to face her anxieties. Nana Osaki may have the spotlight onstage, but she’s haunted by her friend’s absence and by memories of Ren. Yazawa underlines that “winning” at life or romance doesn’t necessarily eradicate the emptiness inside.

• Dreams vs. reality 

A huge motif. Both Nanas arrive in Tokyo brimming with ideals—Hachi wants her fairytale love, Nana O. wants rock stardom. They briefly enjoy that shining moment of hope, only for reality to hit like a sledgehammer. Hachi realizes fairy tales can be hollow, and Nana O. discovers the music industry can be crippling. Yazawa’s telling us: “We think we’ll be happy once we get X, Y, or Z… but guess what? Real-life insecurities and baggage follow you everywhere.”

• The weight of time & regret 

NANA is laced with flash-forwards, revealing how characters grapple with “Could I have done it differently?” Hachi mourns letting Nobu go; Nana Osaki wonders if she and Ren could have avoided tragedy. The story pulses with a wistful sense of “it’s too late,” intensifying the bittersweet narrative that resonates with anyone who’s ever made a decision they can’t take back.

• Japan & the social pressures on women 

Finally, NANA is a stark portrait of how cultural expectations box women in. Hachi is pushed toward the role of a housewife—even if it means misery—while Nana O. aims to live free but pays in loneliness and economic strain. Yazawa deftly exposes that neither path is simple, as Japanese culture can judge the “rebellious woman” and suffocate the “domestic” one.

Collectively, these themes—loneliness, broken dreams, regrets, and societal constraints—are what make NANA so heartbreakingly genuine. No clean endings, no magical solutions; just flawed people wrestling with internal scars and external demands. And that brutal honesty is exactly why we still can’t let go of NANA. In all the chaos and gloom, there’s an unexplainable magnetism, a raw reflection of our own struggles.

Cultural impact: why NANA remains so potent in 2025

You’d think a manga launched in 2000 and paused since 2009 might fade into obscurity. Not NANA. This series left such a deep mark that, in 2025, we’re still discussing, debating, and recommending it. Ai Yazawa’s refusal to play by the shōjo rulebook—her raw approach to toxic love, her gritty portrayal of codependent relationships, her iconic punk aesthetic—catapulted NANA to legendary status.

1. A landmark shōjo tackling real-world toxicity 

It was among the earliest mainstream shōjo works to handle adult-like relationship issues—jealousy, emotional blackmail, dependency. Readers back then were shocked (in the best possible way) to see characters facing heartbreak that felt genuinely adult. This opened the door for more mature shōjo titles, showing everyone that “for girls” didn’t have to mean sweet or trivial.

2. The rock soundtrack & visuals that shaped pop culture 

Ai Yazawa’s fictional bands, Blast and Trapnest, are legendary to the point that many still remember the music from the 2006 anime (shout-out to Anna Tsuchiya and Olivia Lufkin for those chart-climbing tracks). For legions of fans, NANA was their first glimpse of a more raw, edgy style in a “girls’ manga.” Nana Osaki’s punk/Vivienne Westwood look became a subcultural phenomenon—cosplays, brand collaborations, you name it.

3. the allure of an unfinished legend 

The manga hit a high point emotionally, then abruptly ended when Ai Yazawa went on hiatus for health reasons. Ever since, fans have been longing, hoping, theorizing: “Will she come back to finish it?” The mystery has only deepened NANA’s cult status. It’s like a love story that never got its final chapter—haunting, frustrating, and irresistibly compelling.

4. Still relevant to modern debates on gender & love 

By 2025, you’d hope societal pressures on women might’ve changed. But as NANA shows, many core issues—balancing career vs. marriage, dealing with manipulative partners, and facing paternalistic judgments—are still front and center. Hence, it remains startlingly relatable.

Summed up:

• An unfinished myth: the open ending keeps the fandom feverish.

• Evergreen resonance: social power imbalances and love struggles haven’t magically fixed themselves.

• A generational touchstone: NANA took shōjo to a darker, more adult place, and that evolution hasn’t lost its edge.

So yes, we’re still obsessed with this heartbreak-laden, rock-fueled, feminist-leaning manga. NANA might be incomplete, but ironically, that’s a huge part of its enduring charm.

Final thoughts – “NANA, the work that helps you grow”

This has been our special Cappuccino & Croissant deep-dive on NANA. If there’s one takeaway, it’s that NANA isn’t just a tragedy-laced romance. It’s a mirror for our own dreams, illusions, mistakes—and how we cope with them. Whether you see yourself in Hachi’s codependence or Nana Osaki’s fierce pride, you’ll likely emerge from this manga feeling you’ve learned something about your own relationships. Ai Yazawa nails that delicate interplay where love and friendship are bound up in painful choices, regrets, and a searing honesty that hits you right in the gut.

And you—what’s that one NANA moment that blew your mind or changed how you see yourself? Let me know on social media or drop a voice message; we want your stories, your theories, your rants, and your unfiltered feels about this unfinished masterpiece that still haunts us all.

Thanks for tuning in to Cappuccino & Croissant! Take care of your dreams, keep an eye on your illusions, and remember: sometimes you have to get a little lost before you can really find yourself.

Before you go: if you enjoyed this special NANA edition, make sure to follow my show on your favorite podcast platform, toss me a like or five-star rating, and share it with your bestie—or your worst crush, I don’t judge!

Extra goodies: if you’re into pop-culture analysis, check out my books, Red Flags and Love Songs, for a behind-the-scenes look at the K-Pop industry (complete with drama galore). And if spoken word is your jam, head over to SoundCloud for The Free Verse Chronicles, a modern, urban take on poetry that carries a hint of rock ‘n’ roll attitude.

So go ahead: subscribe, comment, react—we love reading your feedback, even the spicy critiques (especially the spicy ones!). You’ll find us on Instagram, Twitter, TikTok… wherever you hang out online. Keep fueling your passion for stories, banging music, and unapologetically bold analysis. Until next time on Cappuccino & Croissant—take care, and most importantly, stay curious!